It is important to consider food web interactions when assessing how well mesopredator culling programs work

Publisert 27.11.2020

Management of endangered species by culling mesopredators is increasingly common. To what extent such programs work as intended, is less clear. In a new study, COAT researchers evaluated the impact of red fox culling on a threatened ptarmigan species.

Henden et al. 2020 got the front cover of Journal of Applied Ecology nr. 1, January 2021. Photo: Rolf A. Ims.
Henden et al. 2020 got the front cover of Journal of Applied Ecology nr. 1, January 2021. Photo: Rolf A. Ims.


Increasing populations of mesopredators, such as foxes and corvids, are in many places suspected to cause declines in vulnerable wildlife. This has led to mesopredator decimation actions (culling) becoming a common management action. However, many mesopredators are highly mobile and resilient. Therefore, culling actions need to be intense, long-term and operate on large scales, which leads to logistical and financial constraints. This represents a common challenge to impact assessments of large-scale management interventions, which would require a proper spatial replication of action and controls. Hence, extensive temporal replication (i.e. time series) and accounting for potentially confounding drivers may alleviate this problem.           

In alpine-arctic tundra, the red fox (Vulpes vulpes) has been increasing during the last 50 years. Simultaneously, many bird species have declined, including the willow ptarmigan (Lagopus lagopus), likely due to increased predation. In a new study (Henden et al. 2020 JApplEcol), we have assessed the impact of a long-term (12-year) and spatially extensive (~3500km2) red fox decimation program on the red listed willow ptarmigan (Lagopus lagopus) in the Norwegian low Arctic. Ptarmigan populations have been monitored annually in both the impact area and in an adjacent no-action area, including a 5-year period before the action commenced.  

A Before-After-Control-Impact-Paired-Series (BACIPS) analysis without food web covariates revealed that red fox decimation has likely curbed the decline of the ptarmigan population in the impact area, resulting in a ~25 % higher density compared to the no-action area. However, the dynamics of other drivers within the food web masked the effect in the simple BACIPS analysis. Hence, accounting for three food web drivers (small rodent abundance, carrion availability and ptarmigan harvest) as covariates in the statistical model, resulted in a more unbiased impact estimate that amounted to ~40 % higher ptarmigan density (4.3 more ptarmigan/km2) in the red fox impact area.  

Figure. Upper panel: Time series of ptarmigan density (log). Aligned are estimates from the BACIPS analysis of mean density (with 95% CI) before and after the fox culling action for the Varanger impact region and Ifjord-Tana control region, respectively.

Lower panel: Estimated impact of the red fox culling action on ptarmigan population density (log-scale) adjusted for the influence of food web covariates (black line and filled symbols). For comparison, dark grey line and open circles denote the unadjusted estimates from the BACIPS model (“After”) in the upper panel.


With this study, we are among the first to provide evidence of the role of the recent expansion of red fox in the decline of tundra bird populations. Interestingly, we show that red fox decimation programs may curb such declines, given that management actions are large-scale and long-term. The accuracy of impact assessments can be increased by conducting and including proper monitoring of drivers of food web dynamics that also affect the target species. This is especially relevant for declining bird populations in boreal and arctic food webs, which are governed by strong multi-annual interaction cycles (e.g. small rodents).


Full paper

More news

Jul12 COAT predicts this year’s ptarmigan density in Finnmark
Created by Leif Einar Støvern on 7/12/2022 8:24:00 AM

COAT has modeled the population fluctuations of willow ptarmigan in Finnmark and looked at what inf...
Read More..

Jun13 One more PhD in COAT
Created by Leif Einar Støvern on 6/13/2022 3:24:00 AM

On 8th of June Eivind Kleiven has successfully defended his PhD thesis “ Population cycles in sma...
Read More..

Jun08 Fresh PhD in COAT
Created by Leif Einar Støvern on 6/8/2022 8:24:00 AM

On the 3rd of June Pedro Da Silva Nicolau has successfully defended his PhD thesis “ Boreal roden...
Read More..

Jun02 New PhD in COAT
Created by Leif Einar Støvern on 6/2/2022 11:24:00 AM

On 24th of May Isabell Eischeid has successfully defended her PhD thesis “ T undra vegetation ecol...
Read More..

May13 Automatic sound stations and bioacoustics: The backbone of COAT Varanger's annual winter field work on ptarmigan
Created by Leif Einar Støvern on 5/13/2022 1:24:00 AM

Members of COAT Varanger’s ptarmigan module has recently deployed the sound stations for this year’...
Read More..

Apr29 Monitoring of gyrfalcons, golden eagles and ravens in Varanger
Created by Leif Einar Støvern on 4/29/2022 1:24:00 AM

COAT have in collaboration with Rovfuglgruppa I Vest-Finnmark, for the fourth consecutive year, che...
Read More..

Apr19 New study started in Svalbard
Created by Leif Einar Støvern on 4/19/2022 8:24:00 AM

We have started a large carcass-project in Svalbard and the first pictures is already collected. It...
Read More..

Feb18 Track our red foxes online!
Created by Leif Einar Støvern on 2/18/2022 2:24:00 AM

You may have heard about our gps-tracking project of red foxes on Varanger Peninsula. You can now p...
Read More..

Feb09 COAT related publications from the SUSTAIN project
Created by Leif Einar Støvern on 2/9/2022 12:24:00 PM

SUSTAIN was a nationally coordinated research project funded by the Research Council of Norway du...
Read More..

Dec08 Drone-based mapping of changed vegetation
Created by Leif Einar Støvern on 12/8/2021 2:24:00 AM

COAT researchers monitor vegetation disturbances by biotic and abiotic factors, such as herbivory a...
Read More..